What do you think about being given a 1 star review without a convincing reason
I want to share some bad experiences and opinion, and discuss with you all sellers. meantime hope Amazon will take this issue seriously.
Last month, I met a buyer sent a message after he/she received the product, the message told me there's some quality problem and threaten to get full refund without returning, or gave 1 star on both seller profile and product listing. but no detail and pictures. I agree to give all money back but return the product. then my listing get a 1 star review. it's a disaster for a new listing. I appealed but Amazon did nothing for it.
I think Amazon should process 1 start review carefully and cautiously, must there is reliable season.
To my surprised, i found some buyers are professional 1 star reviewers!!!!!
Did you meet this issure?
The first picture is the buyer who give 1 star to my listing. others are found someone's listing.
What do you think about being given a 1 star review without a convincing reason
I want to share some bad experiences and opinion, and discuss with you all sellers. meantime hope Amazon will take this issue seriously.
Last month, I met a buyer sent a message after he/she received the product, the message told me there's some quality problem and threaten to get full refund without returning, or gave 1 star on both seller profile and product listing. but no detail and pictures. I agree to give all money back but return the product. then my listing get a 1 star review. it's a disaster for a new listing. I appealed but Amazon did nothing for it.
I think Amazon should process 1 start review carefully and cautiously, must there is reliable season.
To my surprised, i found some buyers are professional 1 star reviewers!!!!!
Did you meet this issure?
The first picture is the buyer who give 1 star to my listing. others are found someone's listing.
26 respuestas
Michelle_Amazon
Hello @Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy,
I am sorry to hear that the customer gave you a one star review for making them return the product. As you should have the proof that they stated they would do this in your buyer seller messaging, please create a case with a link to that message so you can show that they said this was going to happen if they didn't get to keep the product.
Please provide the case ID if you need help after they fully investigate.
Thanks,
Michelle
Michelle_Amazon
Hi @Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy,
Please know that they are still reviewing, I just can't share any outcome due to confidentiality reasons, so all I can say is that they will take any action they feel is necessary.
While I can't share the outcome, continue to watch the listings and if you do not see any action in another week, please let me know so I can look further into this.
Thanks for your understanding!
Michelle
Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy
Hi @Michelle_Amazon,
Got it, thank you very much!
Look forward to good news！
Have a good day!
Michelle_Amazon
Hello @Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy,
I am requesting an update on this again, however, they will likely not let me know what their outcome is due to confidentiality of the customer, but know that I am pushing on this from my end.
I will follow up once they reply back.
Thanks,
Michelle
Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy
Hi @Michelle_Amazon,
Thanks for your updates.
Look forward to next one.
Have a good day!
Michelle_Amazon
Hello @Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy,
Unfortunately, the team will not provide me the outcome of their investigation due to confidentiality of the investigation. Unfortunately, I don't have any further information I can provide, but know that they do investigate all of the concerns that are sent to them.
I wish there was more that I could do, but thank you for your understanding.
Regards,
Michelle
Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy
Hi @Michelle_Amazon,
Thank you very much although the answer is not the one i wait for! I don't understand what the investigation team did when they faced the fact!!!
Today, I just have a look all the reviews of Quantumx, who left 1 star review on my listing, he/she only give sellers 1 star ones.(FYI picture), isn't that strange？？？
I do hope Amazon do not condone those who use threatening means to defraud goods.
Have a good day!
Michelle_Amazon
Hi @Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy,
The team stated they will investigate, however, they will not provide me the outcome due to confidentiality reasons. Unfortunately, I have done all I can and the final decision is up to the communities team. I have provided them all of these product reviews as well, but again, I cannot make them remove any reviews.
Thank you for your understanding.
Michelle
Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy
Hi @Michelle_Amazon,
I do appreciate all you did!
I'll keep track of this case，and hope the investigate-team do right judgement ASAP!
Have a good week!
Michelle_Amazon
Hi @Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy,
I will update you as soon as I have more information.
Have a great weekend!
Michelle_Amazon
Hi @Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy,
I have escalated this issue multiple times and their final decision is that they will not remove the review. They stated that it is not out of compliance each time and that they will not review this again. I am sorry that I cannot do more, but thank you for your understanding.
Regards,
Michelle
Seller_LBQZt4wWsFSsy
Hi @Michelle_Amazon,
There is another evidence to prove that this buyer “Quantumx” profited from misusing platform policies（FYI the picture）
This buyer always ask for money back and not return by threatening to give negative reviews, if seller refuse，the buyer left 1 start review；if seller compromises，the buyer may left 5 star review. These reviews are not objective and fair, so many false reviews not only is ham for Amazon's value，but also is violation of some law!!
Hope this is helpful for you to deal with my case!
Have a good day!
